Ascribing Notions and Narratives to God without Knowledge Is among the Features of Disbelief

آحمد صبحي منصور Ýí 2017-01-16

Ascribing Notions and Narratives to God without Knowledge Is among the Features of Disbelief

Published in January 15, 2017

Translated by Ahmed Fathy





1- Disbelief and polytheism are synonymous in the Quran; they are in two levels: 1) in terms of behavior, they mean aggression, injustices, violence, terrorism, and transgression, especially under the banner of religion, and using falsely the name of God, and 2) in terms of faith and tenets in one's heart, they mean to deify mortals (saints, deities, gods, prophets, etc.) along with God and to sanctify 'holy' books/tomes, names, and tangible things, relics, and items (e.g., tombs and mausoleums) for which God sent down no authority at all, but polytheists deem such things as part of religion.    

2- This disbelief or polytheism in terms of tenets and notions inside one's mind and heart is divided into two types as follows.

2/1: Disbelief/polytheism in terms of practice: it is exemplified in deifying and sanctifying mausoleums ('holy' tombs) by worshipping at them in a form of pilgrimage during specific times or feasts/festivals.

2/2: Disbelief/polytheism in terms of knowledge: it is exemplified in believing in notions/ideas written in 'holy' ancient tomes/volumes, which are sanctified books written during the Middle Ages, but adherents to them claim that their narratives/hadiths is part of divine discourse or God's Sharia legislations and therefore part of their 'Islam'.

3- The vast majority of the Muhammadans fall into the trap of polytheism in terms of practice by worshipping at devilish, Satanist mausoleums made 'holy', like the one ascribed to Muhammad (as his assumed tomb) in Yathreb, Arabia, and tombs/mausoleums in the Arab world and in Egypt ascribed to Al-Hussein (Muhammad's murdered grandson), tomb of Ali (Muhammad's in-law and supreme Shiite deity) in Iraq, and other tombs ascribed to Muhammad's female progeny (Zeinab and Nafisa), as well as tombs of imams and sheikhs of Sunnite and Sufi religions: Al-Shafei, Al-Badawi, Al-Shazily, Abou Hanifa, etc. The vast majority of the Muhammadans fall into the trap of polytheism in terms of knowledge; they deify and sanctify ancient books of traditions that contain hadiths/narratives as well as 'religious' legislations of fiqh never mentioned by God and are never part of Islam. The Muhammadans forcibly ascribe such notions and ideas to Islam and to God, despite the fact that most of these notions are discrepant, disputable, questionable, inconsistent, unbelievable, and illogical as per various views sheikhs and imams and all of them contradict the Quran and disagree with it all the time within all topics. Besides, the Muhammadans fall into the trap of polytheism by deifying and invoking the authors of such books as saints/'holy' men who are irrefutable and infallible, such as the volumes of the book of hadiths "Sahih Al-Bokhary" (i.e., literally, 'the true book of Al-Bokhary') by Al-Bokhary to the Sunnites, the volumes of ''Al-Kafi'' (i.e., literally, 'the sufficient book') by Al-Kulayni to the Shiites, and the volumes of ''Ehiaa Olom Eddine'' (i.e., literally: 'revival of religious sciences') by Al-Ghazaly to the Sufis.      

4- Very few Muhammadans fall into the trap of polytheism in terms of aggressive behavior; those are terrorists, especially the Sunnite Wahabi ones (e.g., the terrorist MB and Salafists as well as Al-Qaeda and ISIS). Their heinous crimes and terrorist operations include massacring the innocent peaceful people and sabotage, and they base their crimes on false sharia laws/legislations and fabricated hadiths/narratives of their earthly, man-made religions that contradict Islam (i.e., the Quran: Quranism), and yet, those terrorists/murderers assume they are the 'guided' ones and nearer to God! shame on them!    

5- All of the above show clearly that the Muhammadans are ignoramuses; they are so ignorant as far as religion of the Quran is concerned. From the Quran, we discern that such ignorance, polytheism, and disbelief are linked with a shared, common feature: namely, to ascribe notions, ideas, tenets, and narratives to God without knowledge.      



Ascribing to God without knowledge: polytheism in terms of practice:

   Mr. A. Magdy is a very shrewd and successful merchant, who is very meticulous in his expenditure, making profits, and trade deals and so on. Mr. Magdy makes sure all the time that people do not deceive him when he buys anything and is keen to gain as much money from potential buyers in his trade. Mr. Magdy is a very religious sort of person, as he does many acts of charity and good deeds with others, as per his perception as a Sunnite Muhammadan, within feasts celebrating saints like Al-Hussein and Zeinab in Cairo, Egypt, and he worships regularly at the mausoleums of all saints and donate money as vows there at boxes fixed there for that purpose at the mausoleums. Yet, despite the meticulousness of Mr. Magdy, he never asks about the money he donates in mausoleums: does Al-Hussein make use of such money? How come if this saint is immortal in his tomb that he would spend that money? If he is a dead saint, who does take that money? Mr. Magdy does not know that there are five mausoleums for Al-Hussein in the Arab world and that each of them claim to house the severed head of Al-Hussein. Did Al-Hussein had five heads?! Why if he is 'holy' that he could not avoid being killed?! Another question that has never crossed the mind of Mr. Magdy is as follows: why a severed head be made 'holy' in the first place and be worshipped?! Mr. Magdy forgets all about the fact that God in the Quran has said the following to Al-Hussein's grandfather (i.e., Prophet Muhammad): "It is not a matter of your concern…" (3:128). We are to believe the Quran of course, and we pose this question: would the severed head of Al-Hussein be immortal or can it influence matters in this world or the next one?! Hence, Mr. Magdy is presenting money/vows from his earnings to a thing of which he has no knowledge at all and will be judged by God about such falsehoods ascribed to God's religion. God says the following about those polytheists in terms of false tenets and faiths invented and cherished as 'true' ones inside the heart and mind like Mr. Magdy: "And they allocate, to something they do not know, a share of what We have provided for them. By God, you will be questioned about what you have been inventing. " (16:65).

Ascribing to God without knowledge: polytheism in terms of knowledge:

1- Again: Mr. Magdy is a very shrewd and successful merchant, who is very meticulous in his expenditure, making profits, and trade deals and so on. Mr. Magdy makes sure all the time that people do not deceive him when he buys anything and is keen to gain as much money from potential buyers in his trade. Mr. Magdy is a very religious sort of person, as he does many acts of charity and good deeds with others, as per his perception as a Sunnite Muhammadan. Mr. Magdy is keen on donating money to projects of building more mosques all over Cairo (which houses already millions of them!). Once Mr. Magdy hears a bearded man/sheikh in white screaming in the streets via the loudspeakers: (Donate, our brethren, to build the new mosque, in order to earn your palaces in Paradise!), he would stop his car and donate money to the hand of the bearded man. Mr. Magdy assumes that whenever he donates money to projects of mosques under construction, he would have a new palace in Heaven, as the hadith ascribed to Muhammad asserts that those who participate in building a mosque to God, even to build a mosque within the area of two square feet, God will build him a palace in Paradise. Every night, Mr. Magdy would dream of the number of palaces in his name and honor in Heaven. Despite his meticulousness, Mr. Magdy is a dumb jack-ass as far as religion is concerned; he never cares to verify what is true and what is false among widespread dominant religious notions in his society. Mr. Magdy never uses his mind at all as far as religion is concerned; as he lose readily his money and meticulousness once he hears someone says (Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings of Allah upon him said that … … etc.). Mr. Magdy never asks himself these pivotal questions: Was this speaker/interlocutor alive in the 7th century during Muhammad's lifetime to hear him say anything?! Who could ever claim, among hadiths narrators/fabricators, to have heard Muhammad himself within a first-had experience?! Besides, such false hadith insults God by making Him a constructor building countless palaces to those donating money to build mosques! This is very insulting to God! Shame on all Sunnites who believe such nonsense! Besides, is there any mosque whose area is two square feet?! Is it a mosque for birds or insects?! Or is it for heedless, brainless human cattle?! Would God reward such donators with palaces in Paradise?! This false hadith entails or presupposes that these donators will enter Paradise even if they commit major sins and crimes! Would Hitler, for instance, enter Paradise to enjoy his palace if he had built a mosque anywhere?! The Muhammadans who believe such false hadith forget that Paradise and Hell are not created yet; they will be created on the Day of Resurrection, as per the Quran. Despite the meticulousness of Mr. Magdy in all worldly matters and trade deals and affairs, he never uses his noodles (if he has got any brains) as far as religious issues are concerned. Mr. Magdy exemplifies those Muhammadans who believe in those misguiding, devilish hadiths/fabricated narratives.                   

2- Mr. Magdy would readily believe any hadiths once he hears the phrase: (Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings of Allah upon him said that … … etc.) uttered in pulpits inside mosques by imams and clergymen or by any laymen in streets. When Mr. Magdy has heard the hadith fabricated by Al-Bokhary (and others) ascribed to Muhammad that any Muslim sinners will get out of Hell after spending few days for expatiating their sins (i.e., as if in a sort of hellish purgatory) and will be made to enter Paradise merely because they are born as 'Muslims' and they 'love' the Quran, Mr. Magdy felt happy and overjoyed; he paid a donation to the preacher/sheikh of the pulpit inside the mosque and drove his car as fast as he can to enter the discothèque/night club, where he got drunk after drinking bottles of wine and he had sex with whores till daybreak. Mr. Magdy is quite 100% sure that he can go on sinning for the rest of his life, since he believes the-above mentioned hadiths about sinning Muslims going to Paradise eventually after visiting Hell for few days! Mr. Magdy believes in the myth that Prophet Muhammad will intercede on his behalf to make him get out of Hell and to enter Paradise! Mr. Magdy never casts doubt on such a devilish hadith (and all hadiths are devilish of course); he forgets all about the fact that the Quran refutes such a myth in these Quranic verses: "And they say, "The Fire will not touch us except for a number of days." Say, "Have you received a promise from God-God never breaks His promise-or are you saying about God what you do not know?" Indeed, whoever commits misdeeds, and becomes besieged by his iniquities-these are the inmates of the Fire, wherein they will dwell forever. As for those who believe and do righteous deeds-these are the inhabitants of Paradise, wherein they will dwell forever." (2:80-82). God says to all sorts of polytheists (including the Muhammadans): "… are you saying about God what you do not know?" (2:80). We must ponder that Quranic phrase very deeply.   

3- Mr. Magdy readily believes any hadiths if the interlocutor or author ascribes it to Muhammad; he never cast doubt on hadiths at all as he does not know that all hadiths were fabricated and written down more than 200 years after Muhammad's death! Mr. Magdy does not know that following these hadiths is following the footsteps of Satan/devils that must urge falsehoods, sinning, and immorality, as all devilish people ascribe to God what they do not know as if it were part of the so-called Sunna, which for the Muhammadans overrule and supplant the Quran and deemed as divine revelation! Mr. Magdy never cares to ponder upon God's warning in thee Quranic verses: "… Do not follow the footsteps of Satan. He is to you an open enemy. He commands you to do evil and vice, and to say about God what you do not know." (2:168-169). All imams and clergymen of the Muhammadans say about God what they do not know, and they never heed Quranic warnings at all.      

4- Since Mr. Magdy believes any hadiths/narratives ascribed to Muhammad, he is a Salafist who imitates his forefathers and commits the same sins during Sufi feasts/festivals, deeming his sins as part of religious rituals; Mr. Magdy does not care about the following Quranic warning: "… We have made the devils friends/allies of those who do not believe. And when they commit an indecency, they say, "We found our parents doing this, and God has commanded us to do it." Say, "God does not command indecencies. Are you attributing to God what you do not know?"" (7:27-28). Hence, God says that human devils (like Sunnite imams: al-Bokhary, Al-Shafei, Malik, Ibn Hanbal, etc.) attribute to Him what they do not know, and they have specialized in that sin. When a Quranist would advise Mr. Magdy by asserting the Quranic facts, he will readily accuse this Quranist of being an apostate/heretic infidel who is denying the 'hallowed' Sunna. If a Quranist would warn Mr. Magdy against ascribing to God what he does not know, he would get mad and furious, because Mr. Magdy does not believe in God's Word about prohibited items: "Say, "My Lord has forbidden immoralities-both open and secret-and sin, and unjustified aggression, and that you associate with God anything for which He revealed no sanction, and that you say about God what you do not know."" (7:33). Hence, God prohibits to say about God what we do not know; yet, imams and saints of the Muhammadans have authored countless books of hadiths, Sunna, fiqh, narratives, etc. to ascribe to God a revelation never endorsed by Him, especially by ascribing their falsehoods to Muhammad centuries after his death! Mr. Magdy believes in books of such imams and saints, and for that reason, he discards and denies the Quran: the Word of God.      

5- Those who ascribe to God sons and deities beside Him (e.g., like Christians, among others) are committing the sin of ascribing to God what they do not know: "And they said, "God has taken a son." Be He glorified. He is the Self-Sufficient. His is everything in the heavens and everything on earth. Do you have any proof for this? Or are you saying about God what you do not know?" (10:68); "And to warn those who say, "God has begotten a son." They have no knowledge of this, nor did their forefathers. Grave is the word that comes out of their mouths. They say nothing but a lie." (18:4-5). God wants them to repent: "They disbelieve those who say, "God is the third of three." But there is no deity except the One God. If they do not refrain from what they say, a painful torment will befall those among them who disbelieve. Will they not repent to God and ask His forgiveness? God is Forgiving and Merciful. The Messiah son of Mary was only a messenger, before whom other Messengers had passed away, and his mother was a woman of truth. They both used to eat food. Note how We make clear the revelations to them; then note how deluded they are. Say, "Do you worship, besides God, what has no power to harm or benefit you?" But God: He is the Hearer, the Knower. Say, "O People of the Scripture! Do not exaggerate in your religion beyond the truth; and do not follow the opinions of people who went astray before, and misled many, and themselves strayed off the balanced way."" (5:73-77). The Muhammadans committed the same major sin by claiming that Muhammad is immortal, created before Adam, created from the Light of god before the universe, the universe is created for Muhammad's sake, etc. thus making Muhammadan a supreme god/deity who controls God! such hadiths of the Muhammadans that contain such blasphemous notions are ascribed to God's religion forcibly by devilish human beings who insists on saying about God what you do not know.    



1- The more the Muhammadan imams, preachers, and clergymen ascribe falsehoods to God, the more they grow rich and powerful and their disciples/followers increase. The human herd/cattle among such clergymen include the televangelists in Wahabi/Sunnite and Shiite Satellite channels and they exemplify such misguiding people who grow richer and more powerful with millions of Arabs following them. In contrast, when Quranist preachers would call for a return to the Quran as the only source of Islam and would talk about Quranic tenets and facts, they can never find a place under the sun, because they address those who never desire to see, hear, or discern the Quranic Truth.    

2- If Quranist preachers would talk to Mr. Magdy and exert considerable effort to convince him about anything, they will certainly fail. Mr. Magdy cannot remove the thick veil of falsehoods around his mind and heart and never pays attention as his senses are shut and he cannot think about the Quranic Truth: "And if you call them to guidance, they will not hear. And you see them looking at you, yet they do not see." (7:198); "Who does greater wrong than he, who, when reminded of his Lord's revelations, turns away from them, and forgets what his hands have put forward? We have placed coverings over their hearts, lest they understand it, and heaviness in their ears. And if you call them to guidance, they will not be guided, ever." (18:57); "And if you invite them to guidance, they will not follow you. It is the same for you, whether you invite them, or remain silent." (7:193). As always, God says nothing but the Truth. 

اجمالي القراءات 5066

للمزيد يمكنك قراءة : اساسيات اهل القران
أضف تعليق
لا بد من تسجيل الدخول اولا قبل التعليق
تاريخ الانضمام : 2006-07-05
مقالات منشورة : 4776
اجمالي القراءات : 49,208,131
تعليقات له : 5,012
تعليقات عليه : 14,166
بلد الميلاد : Egypt
بلد الاقامة : United State

مشروع نشر مؤلفات احمد صبحي منصور

محاضرات صوتية

قاعة البحث القراني

باب دراسات تاريخية

باب القاموس القرآنى

باب علوم القرآن

باب تصحيح كتب

باب مقالات بالفارسي