Jihad in Palestine

الأربعاء 25 نوفمبر 2009


نص السؤال:
What about the real Islamic Jihad in Palestine?
آحمد صبحي منصور :
According to the Quran they have the right to fight those who are fighting them. This does not include fighting the civilians of course.
In this regard we have to remember that war in the real Islamic jurisprudence is the last option, it is an exception while the peaceful struggle is the general rules. You fight if you have to, if there is no peaceful way else to solve this problem.
Peace is the best Islamic solution in dealing among individuals and in dealing between countries. Peaceful efforts include forgiveness and reconciliation. God says in the Quran:” And the servants of the Almighty Lord are those who are walking in the earth modestly, and if the ignorant insult them they say: “peace”. [25: 63]. Also He says “Then forgive them and say: “peace”. They will come to know. [43:89].
Peace is the best solution because by peace you are addressing the noble values inside your enemy, giving him the chance to correct his bad deeds. But by the war you are invoking his bad side. After thousands of centuries and hundreds of wars mankind realizes lately this Quranic value of peace while the fanatic Muslims are denying it.
In November 1987, I was in the notorious prison of Torah near Cairo because I advocated the real Islamic values of peace, tolerance, justice, democracy and human rights proving that the so –called Sunna has the culture of bigotry and fanaticism. In prison, the intifada or the rising of the Palestinians had begun. The prison was full of Muslim fanatics who were eager to see the Intifada changed from stoning the Israeli soldiers to fighting them by machine guns. I was so scared to speak up, but in my dreams in that time, I hoped that the Palestinians should demonstrate peacefully and silently with white flags saying “We want freedom. We want justice. We want peace.” By this way they would get their state and save all these lives from the two sides.
By the Salafi Wahaby culture, Muslims forget the high Islamic value; Peace. In the same time there are great leaders who were aware of the value of peace as the perfect way in resistance, and by peaceful means they got freedom for their people. Mahatma Ghandi of India addressed the British consciousness directly by his peaceful humble struggle and got the independence for India, but the fanatic Indian Muslims have divided India and created Pakistan as one of the biggest mistakes in the last century. Marten Luther King, by his peaceful struggle got the civil rights for the African Americans refusing to use guns because the other side has more guns. Nilsson Mandela in his prison for 30 years defeated the whit regime in his country because he is a man of peace. Those are great men and great Muslims also in the realm of peace.
In the other hand, the first struggle did by the P.L.O was destroying a school bus full of children in Israel, then the other kind of struggle was hijacking the civilian aero planes. The current struggle is by the suicide bombers which is advocating by the Salafi fanatic culture and its leaders and their verdicts on line.



مقالات متعلقة بالفتوى :
اجمالي القراءات 7254
التعليقات (2)
1   تعليق بواسطة   هشام احمد     في   السبت 28 نوفمبر 2009
[43812]


Dear Dr. Ahmad

I’m believer in piece myself, and I totally agree with you that civilians on both sides should not be part war , and that peace is our only way to end the conflict.

I also know that there are people in Israel who share same morals, however truth to be said they’re the minority and have been always far from decision making in Israel.


When you look at the history of our conflict, the first thing you notice is that, whenever the Palestinians drop resistance and go for peace, the more Israel violation increases immediately , more land ceased more settlements …

Israel behavior for the last decades sees peace as weakness and a chance to seize more, how can peace alone achieve any results with such a pragmatic &hostile mentality?


2   تعليق بواسطة   هشام احمد     في   السبت 28 نوفمبر 2009
[43813]


Am glad someone has finally asked about this sensitive issue, following my previous words, don’t you think that Palestinians resistance within borders of 67 and not against any civilians should be allowed?


 


أضف تعليق
لا بد من تسجيل الدخول اولا قبل التعليق
تاريخ الانضمام : 2006-07-05
مقالات منشورة : 4008
اجمالي القراءات : 34,877,438
تعليقات له : 4,378
تعليقات عليه : 12,985
بلد الميلاد : Egypt
بلد الاقامة : United State

مشروع نشر مؤلفات احمد صبحي منصور

محاضرات صوتية

قاعة البحث القراني

باب دراسات تاريخية

باب القاموس القرآنى

باب علوم القرآن

باب تصحيح كتب

باب مقالات بالفارسي


سهر المحمديين : قلت فى حلقة من برنامج لحظات قرآنية أن آية ((فَإِنَّم َا هِيَ زَجْرَةٌ وَاحِدَةٌ *...

نتمنى جهادك فى الحق: شكرا لك دكتور احمد صبحي على نشر اقتراحي في الموقع . انا الان مقيمة في احد الدول العربية و...

بين الزنا واللمم: قرأت على موقعكم فى شأن الزنا ان الزنا فقط هو الايلاج فقط، واريد بعض التوضيح والاجابة...

عبادة المال : اعتقد أن المال هو سبب الصراعات الفردية وعلى مستوى المجتمع وعلى مستوى العالم . لماذا لا...

لحمة العيد الكبير: فى مناسبة عيد الأضحى أنا محتار .. هل اشترى ذبيحة وأوزع لحمها على الفقراء ، أم بنفس الثمن...

وهديناه النجدين : ما معنى : (وهديناه النجدين ) ؟ ...

poor like me can see: about the miracle in number inside the COREAN and I read your comment you are with for...

سدوم وعمورة: لما وصفت مملكة آل سعود بالمملكة السدومية العمورية ، جاء لذهنى هذا السؤال : لماذا لم يذكر...

أنا أخطأت ..ولكن ..: العزيز د. منصور اشك رك و أقدر لك وقوقك فردا في وجه تيار جارف لأكثر من 30 سنه. ذكرت أكثر...

خل الكحول: الخل الذي يستعمله عامة الناس ومكتوب عليه (خل الكحول)، هل هو جائز بارك الله فيك؟...

بين الاخلاص والنية: يا شيحنا أنت هاجمت حديث إنما الأعمال بالنيات . ماذا لو كانت نيتى فى الخير ؟...

الصيام والحساب الفلك: الدكتور احمد صبحي منصور المحترم بعد ان قرات على موقعكم ان الصيام بالحساب وليس بالرؤيا هل...

الحكم المستقبلى : ما قولك فى ان الله جل وعلا قال عن بعض الناس وهم أحياء أنهم من أهل النار . اليس هذا حكما...

قراءة القرآن الكريم: كيف أقرأ القرأن الكريم ’ هل أقرأه كاملا من البداية الى النهاية ’ أم أقرأ كل يوم سورة وأعديها...

تفاحة آدم : ما اصل تفاحة ادم ابو البشر السلام عليكم ورحمه الله وبركاته ..الاغلب يعلم قصة خلق ادم وزوجه...

more