Search:
From the Archive
The Lie of”The Grave torture and the bald serpent”( part one )
Building Churches is a recognized right in
Statement on the Hateful Speech against Muslims by Republican Presidential Contenders
The Double Punishment on the Last Day for Clergymen
El Salvador Truth Commission
Rashad Khalifa, the American Covenant Messenger
A Message to Our Beloved Quranists: We Would Like To Have This Simple Means of Support For the Sake of Islam
Égypte : l'étrange histoire de Mohamed el-Ghanam
With the current Egyptian revolution, the countdown for Wahhabism just
Ponderings on the Quranic Phrase "Pharaoh Exalted himself as Superior on Earth, and Divided its People into Factions. He Persecuted a Group of Them..." (28:4), PARTS I, II and III
Conclusion
Jewish Sorrow Justifying the Sorrow of Others
About the Quranic Stories and the Quranic Chapter Twelve
About our Pilgrimage Journey to Mecca - PART II
The Quranic Terminology: Egyptian Prison
The Danger of Getting Married without a Waiting Period for Women
Quranic Terminology: Truth/True/Truly/Truthful: (3) Within Dealing with People and with God
Religious freedom between Islam and fanatic Muslims
Has decreed mercy upon himself
The Historic Roots of Salafi Wahhabism Movements
astrological Vs naked eye method
Determining Ramadan

This a translation for a question posted at this link:

http://www.ahl-alquran.com/arabic/show_fatwa.php?main_id=57

Determining Ramadan

Question text:

With the end of the month of Ramadan... We are still suffering from the issue of determining the beginning and end of Ramadan. As is well known, almost all Muslims rely on Hadith attributed to the Prophet peace be upon him, which is “Fast upon seeing it, and break your fast upon seeing it”. So what is the truth on this subject, as we see this difference and contrast at the beginning of the month of Ramadan, even among contiguous small states, as well as sometimes the difference in determining the beginning of the Eid al-Fitr.

Ahmed Subhi Mansour’s reply:

As a manifestation of Muslims’ backwardness , is this false Hadith (fast upon seeing it), still adhered to by backward Sunnis up until today. With astronomical calculations there is no conflict in determining Ramadan after fifty years from now or sixty years ago, because it is based on astronomical spreadsheets to track the uniform movement of the moon around the earth in the lunar calendar and the movement of the earth around the sun and its spinning around its axis in the solar calendar.

It is a wonder that the Quran refers to astronomical calculations, in both solar and lunar calenders and the difference between them.

I leave it to you to contemplate and digest the following verses where you would not even take ready-made opinions:

6: 96  (He is) the Cleaver of the daybreak and has made the night for rest and the sun and the moon for calculation. That is the determination of the Mighty, the Knowing.

17: 12  And We have made the night and the day two signs; and We erased the sign of the night and made the sign of the day full of light that you may seek grace from your Lord and may know the count of years and calculations. And everything We have explained in details.

55: 5  The sun and the moon are made punctual.

18: 25  And (it is said) they tarried in their Cave three hundred years, and add nine


The views and opinions of authors whose articles and comments are posted on this site do not necessarily reflect the views of IQC.